Or, who is the strawman here? This is my second post reflecting on the recent American Political Science Association annual meeting. The last one expressed concern about a new trend in the study of international politics. This one will focus on a long-standing issue that just doesn’t seem to go away: the refusal of certain research areas to actually engage with the literature they see as insufficient. The attack This incident occurred at an otherwise interesting panel. The papers, mostly by junior scholars, discussed different manifestations of public religion. Then a senior scholar who...








