Long ago, Dan Drezner posted about the imposter syndrome. The basic idea is that many folks feel as if they will be found out, that there are other folks out there that are smarter, more informed and that one is just getting away with being less than that until eventually getting found out.
That piece resonated with me way back then, and it was funny to hear multiple people raise it this week in Toronto at the ISA. I suddenly realized why this might be the case: there are so many impressive people doing impressive stuff that everyone seems better, more expert and so on, so more folks feel as if they are imposters. I have long said that there is always a bigger fish (thanks to Phantom Menace, yuck).
Well, I got to hang out with some really sharp folks, who are so ambitious, creative, responsible, aware and engaged that when I hear them utter the imposter syndrome stuff, I am really struck. one could attend these conferences and be paralyzed by fear of being found out, paralyzed by how much more impressive these other folks are. Or one can be inspired. I know that I will never be as impressive as these folks, but they do inspire me to be more aware, to figure out what my impact can be, to do better, and be more helpful to others.
Of course, there is only one song to invoke here:
All honest academics should feel like I posters once in awhile. Otherwise you are an unreflective self important jerk.
Steve, we had a similar discussion among PhD students recently. https://irblog.eu/impostor-syndrome-phd/
I agree that it’s inspiring to spend time with smart people, and that this already helps with feeling out of place. But I feel that being humble *all the time* could be too much for people who really have self-esteem issues. That’s why I argued that you should try to be a little “arrogant” from time to time.