What does any faculty member REALLY want for the holidays? It’s not a Lexus, it’s not jewelry, it’s a brand new revise-and-resubmit (R&R) manuscript. It’s really all that is on my list every year. That and, of course, world peace. How can one get an R&R manuscript? So far, I think R&R decisions are the result of the following four conditions: (a) Good work without any serious theoretical or empirical flaws (b) An introduction that doesn’t make the reviewers/editor think the piece is crap from the get-go (c) All reviewers are pretty positive about the manuscript (d) ...